DIANA REPUBLIC

I am relatively new to the whole American Idol thing, which, considering my affinity for bad television, is weird. So help a sister out:

I watched as the judges dismissed a bunch of contestants supporting their decision with the argument that they couldn’t win the whole bag of marbles. So to follow that logic am I to believe that the chemically unbalanced hyena, Tatiana and Nathaniel weepy-pants could actually win? Does America have that kind of sense of humor?